Intellectual Property in Transition: The Several Sides of Overlapping Copyright and Trademark Protection

Document Type

Book Section

Publication Date

1-2021

ISBN

9781108688529

DOI

10.1017/9781108688529.035

Abstract

In this chapter, we address the phenomenon of overlapping trademark and copyright protection under United States (U.S.) law, which represents, in our view, an important example of intellectual property (IP) rights in transition. The Lalique bottles created for Nina Ricci perfumes, for example, may enjoy both copyright and trademark protection. Similarly, cartoon characters are components of copyrightable works (and in some jurisdictions, may be copyrightable works in their own right), but many have also long been registered as trademarks for entertainment services or merchandise. Copyright and trademark protections will overlap when the same object is both an original work of authorship but also serves to identify and distinguish one producer’s goods or services. In theory, the regimes promote different objectives: creativity in the case of copyright, and source identification (or more abstractly, honest market information) in the case of trademarks. The contours of protection differ as well. U.S. copyright law covers original works of authorship; these include a large array of creations, including pictures, architectural works, computer software, and even some works of applied art, so long as they are minimally creative. By contrast, under U.S. law, a trademark need not be creative (though many in fact might be), but it must be “distinctive,” because a sign that does not identify and distinguish goods or services does not fulfil its function of identifying products in the market place as originating with a single source. Accordingly, even though creativity is different from distinctiveness, some trademarks can be original works of authorship and some creative works can be distinctive signs.

First Page

307

Last Page

321

Num Pages

15

Publisher

Cambridge University Press

Editor

Niklas Bruun , Graeme B. Dinwoodie , Marianne Levin, & Ansgar Ohly

Book Title

Transition and Coherence in Intellectual Property Law: Essays in Honour of Annette Kur

Link to Full Text
Buy this Book

Share

COinS