Intellectual Property Protection for Fame, Luxury, Wine, and Spirits: Lex Specialis for a Corporate “Dolce Vita” or a “Good Quality Life”?

Document Type

Book Section

Publication Year





In this chapter, I consider two exceptions to the general provisions (leges generales) of intellectual property law governing the protection of trademarks and geographical indications of origin (GIs). In particular, I consider the leges speciales that have been introduced with respect to two specific subject matters by the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS): anti-dilution protection for well-known marks, as provided in Article 16.3, and anti-usurpation protection for GIs identifying wines and spirits, as provided in Article 23. This latter protection could be extended to other GIs as part of the built-in agenda also introduced by TRIPS. In both cases, these leges speciales enhance the protection granted, respectively, to well-known marks and GIs identifying wines and spirits, beyond the protection granted to marks and GIs in general (which is limited to acts that could amount to confuse and mislead consumers in the marketplace). Based upon this analysis, I explore whether these leges speciales should be viewed merely as an additional example of the growing pressure in favor of enhanced protection that has characterized intellectual property debate in the past decades, or whether Articles 16.3 and 23 of TRIPS could also be explained differently.

First Page


Last Page


Num Pages



ATRIP Intellectual Property Series

Series Title

Intellectual Property and General Legal Principles: Is IP a Lex Specialis?


Edward Elgar


Graeme B. Dinwoodie

Series Editor

Graeme B. Dinwoodie